The short answer
In this article
- 01Every house keeps its own calendar
- 02The houses, and what each one is
- 031. Use one feed for every house
- 042. Know the price before the clock runs down
- 053. Find the lots bid under their recent price
- 064. Searches worth running
- 075. Save the search and let it report
- 086. Watch the card, not only the lot
- 097. Let the reminders tell you when to bid
- 10How each house closes
- 11Before you bid
- 12After the hammer
01
Every house keeps its own calendar
The same graded card can be on eBay tonight, in a Fanatics Collect auction later in the week and in a Goldin or Heritage catalogue next month. Each site has its own search, its own closing times and its own alerts, and none of them tells you what the card sold for anywhere else. Tracking auctions well comes down to three habits: see every house in one place, know the last sold price before the clock runs down, and let alerts do the checking.
02
The houses, and what each one is
These are the marketplaces Assetra follows for graded cards. Some are auction houses with scheduled sales, some are open marketplaces where any seller sets the clock, and some sell at fixed prices only.
- Goldin (goldin.co). An auction house for trading cards and collectibles. Cards are consigned and sold in scheduled auctions that close on a set night.
- Heritage Auctions (ha.com). A Dallas auction house. Trading cards are sold in scheduled auctions alongside comics, coins and sports memorabilia.
- Fanatics Collect (fanaticscollect.com). The marketplace formerly known as PWCC. It runs recurring auctions and fixed-price listings for graded cards.
- eBay (ebay.com). An open marketplace. Any seller can run an auction that ends when they choose, or list a card at a fixed price with Buy It Now.
- ALT (alt.xyz). A marketplace for graded cards, with its own auctions and fixed-price listings.
- SNKRDUNK (snkrdunk.com). A Japanese marketplace for sneakers and trading cards. It holds no auctions: cards are listed at fixed prices, and Assetra follows those listings.
- Cardova (cardova.co.jp). A Japanese site for trading card auctions, with a vault and direct purchase.
- PokeColor (pokecolor.cn). A Chinese trading card platform that sells cards on consignment.
03
1. Use one feed for every house
Assetra’s live auctions page lists graded card lots that are open now on eBay, Fanatics Collect, Goldin, Heritage Auctions, ALT, SNKRDUNK, PokeColor and Cardova. Every lot shows its current bid, the time left and a badge for how far that bid sits under or over the card’s recent price at that grade.
- Filter by house from the table above or the Houses filter on the page, to follow one sale. Leave it open to see them all.
- Filter by closing window to see only what ends in the next hours.
- Narrow by grade, year and price, or search a card by name.
- Sort by ending soonest when you are bidding tonight.
04
2. Know the price before the clock runs down
A current bid means little until the final minutes. The figure to hold on to is what the card has been selling for at that grader and grade, and the badge on each lot measures the bid against it. Open the lot to reach the card’s full sales ledger and decide your ceiling there, while there is time, using the method in how to check comps.
05
3. Find the lots bid under their recent price
This is how we look for value ourselves. Every lot carries a badge that compares its price with what the card has been selling for at that grader and grade: 24% under when the lot is below it and 12% over when it is above. The price in that comparison includes the buyer’s premium where Assetra knows the house’s rate. The reference is the card’s market value from its recent sales, or its last sale where there are too few to work one out.
- Turn on Best value. Best value keeps only the lots priced under that reference and puts the widest gap first. The Under control raises the bar to 10%, 25% or 50% below.
- Add a closing window. An auction with a week to run is nearly always under, because the bidding has not started in earnest. The gap means something in the last hours, so pair Best value with the Ends control: 10% or more under, closing within a day or within two hours.
- Look at Buy It Now too. A fixed price has no clock to wait for. Buy It Now lots priced under their recent sales can be bought as soon as you have checked them.
- Check which way the card is moving. On recent comps each card’s latest sale carries its own badge: the change against the previous sale at the same grade, green when the price rose and red when it fell. A lot bid under a card whose sales are rising is a different proposition from one bid under a card whose sales are falling.
- Treat the badge as a reason to look, not a verdict. Open the lot and read the card’s ledger before you bid. Check that the recent sales are the same card and variety as the lot, that they are recent, and that there are more than one or two of them. A wide gap on a card that rarely sells is often an old or odd comp, not a bargain.
06
4. Searches worth running
The filters combine, and every combination has its own address, so a search can be bookmarked or sent to someone. These are the ones we use most.
- By name. Search a card, a character or a set, then pin the grade: every PSA 10 Charizard open now.
- By year. A year range under Filters keeps the feed to one era: cards from 1996 to 2002.
- By grader and grade. One tier at a time, so the prices you compare are like for like.
- By price. A minimum and a maximum keep the feed inside a budget: PSA 10 lots at $200 or less.
- By population. The Population filter keeps cards with few copies at that grade in the grader’s census: 100 or fewer.
- By autograph. Signed slabs only.
- By house and by sale type. One house or several, auctions or Buy It Now.
Stack them with Best value and a closing window and the feed becomes a short list: lots 25% or more under, closing within 12 hours.
07
5. Save the search and let it report
A search worth running twice is worth saving. With a search or filters set on the live auctions page, Save search keeps it on your account under a name you choose, Best value and the closing window included.
- New since your last visit. Opening a saved search shows the lots that have appeared since you last looked, ahead of the rest.
- Alerts. A saved search can tell you when a new lot matches it and again before a matching lot closes, by push notification or email, chosen for each search.
- One search per job. A card you are waiting for at one grade. An era inside a budget. Best value at 25% under for the grader you collect.
08
6. Watch the card, not only the lot
There are two things to follow, and they do different jobs.
- Save a lot when you have found the copy you want. It joins your watchlist with its bid, time left and last sold price.
- Watch a card at the grades you choose when you are waiting for the right copy. When any house lists a new lot of it you hear about it once, and each new sale reaches you with its price.
A watch keeps to its grade. A PSA 10 watch does not fill up with PSA 9 lots, and a BGS Black Label sale never lands in a plain BGS 10 watch.
09
7. Let the reminders tell you when to bid
A watched auction sends reminders as it runs down, the last one in its final minutes. Each lot gets its own reminder with its own countdown. Alerts collect in the bell on assetra.co and arrive as notifications in the iPhone app, and email or a Discord channel can be switched on in settings.
10
How each house closes
The listed end time is rarely when a lot sells. Most houses use extended bidding: a late bid adds time, so a lot closes only when the bidding stops. The rules differ in two ways that change how you bid. Some houses extend each lot on its own, while others keep the whole auction open for as long as any lot in it is being bid on. And the windows shrink as the night goes on, from minutes down to seconds.
| House | Published close | Extension | What stays open |
|---|---|---|---|
| ALT | Thursday, 9 PM ET, every second week | 2 minutes, falling to 15 seconds | The whole auction |
| Fanatics Collect, Weekly | 7 PM PT | 30 minutes, then 5, then 1 | Each lot |
| Fanatics Collect, Premier | 7 PM PT | 5 minutes, then 2, then 1 | The whole auction |
| Goldin, Weekly | Thursday, 10 PM ET | 15 minutes | Not stated |
| Goldin, Elite | Dates vary | 30 minutes | Not stated |
| Cardova | Sunday, 9 PM JST | 20 minutes, falling to 1, for lots with two or more bids | Each lot |
| eBay | Any time, set by the seller | 60 seconds, where eBay applies it | Each listing |
The detail, from each house’s own page:
- ALT. Auctions run on a two-week cycle: a new one opens each Friday morning and closes on the Thursday evening two weeks later. At 9 PM ET every card enters extended bidding together, and a bid on any card extends the whole auction: by 2 minutes until 9:30, 1 minute until 10:00, 30 seconds until 10:30 and 15 seconds after that. The auction is over when one window passes with no bid on any card. Anyone can bid in extended bidding, with no earlier bid needed. Buyer’s premium: 20%.Source: ALT: Auction Extended Bidding Model, ALT: Auction Functionality.
- Fanatics Collect. Two formats with different closes. In the Weekly auction each lot closes on its own. Extended bidding begins at 7 PM PT, and a lot with no bid between 7:00 and 7:30 closes at 7:30. After 7:30 a lot closes once 5 minutes pass without a bid, and after 8:00 once 1 minute passes. In the Premier auction, which bidders apply to join, one timer covers every lot: 5 minutes from 7 PM PT, reset by a bid on any lot, cut to 2 minutes after 7:30 and to 1 minute after 8:00, when bid increments are halved. The whole Premier auction ends when that timer runs out. Maximum bids carry into extended bidding and third-party sniping services are not allowed. Buyer’s premium in Premier: 20%.Source: Fanatics Collect: Weekly Auction, Fanatics Collect: Premier Auction.
- Goldin. Goldin lists three formats. The Weekly auction opens Tuesday at 8 AM ET, runs 9 days and closes Thursday at 10 PM ET with 15 minutes of extended bidding. Elite auctions run 17 days on dates that vary, with 30 minutes of extended bidding. The Marketplace is fixed price and always open. Buyer’s premium: 22%, with a $19 minimum, listed for all three. That page does not say whether the extension runs lot by lot or who may bid in it, and the Goldin auctions in Assetra’s feed do not all keep to the Thursday calendar, so go by the date and terms on the lot.Source: Goldin: buying and selling options.
- Cardova. Weekly auctions usually open at noon on a Thursday and end on the Sunday of the following week at 9 PM, Japan time. Each lot closes on its own. A lot with one bid or none ends at the scheduled time. A lot with two or more bids goes into Overtime: rounds of 20, 10, 5 and 2 minutes, down to 1 minute. A bid inside a round carries the lot to the next round, and it sells when a round passes with no bid. Overtime is open to every bidder. Bids are in Japanese yen. Buyer’s premium: 6.05% to 11% including tax, by membership rank, with a 330 yen minimum.Source: Cardova: About the auction.
- eBay. Every listing ends at the time its seller chose, so eBay closes around the clock. eBay says it is testing extended bidding on auction listings in some categories: a bid in the final 60 seconds resets the clock to 60 seconds, and the auction ends when the clock runs out with no new bid. eBay Australia has announced the same rule for all auction items listed there. A listing outside those ends at its stated time.Source: eBay: How bidding works, eBay Australia: Introducing Extended Bidding.
- Heritage Auctions. We could not confirm Heritage’s closing rules from its own pages when this guide was checked, so they are not summarised here. The terms are on each lot.
- PokeColor. PokeColor publishes its rules inside its own app, which we could not read. In Assetra’s feed its lots end one at a time, minutes apart, not together as one sale.
- SNKRDUNK. No auctions. Cards are listed at fixed prices, so there is no close to plan around.
What that means on closing night
- A last-second bid does not win on its own. Where bidding extends, a late bid restarts the clock and gives everyone else time to answer. Set your ceiling from the comps beforehand and enter it as a maximum bid.
- The first window can be the only one. In a Fanatics Collect Weekly auction a lot nobody bids on between 7:00 and 7:30 PM PT closes at 7:30. On Cardova a lot with fewer than two bids ends at its scheduled time, with no overtime.
- A whole-auction close can run long. On ALT and in a Fanatics Collect Premier auction your lot stays open while any other lot is still drawing bids, so a bid can arrive well after the published time.
- Be at the screen for the last reminder. Assetra’s reminders count down to the published close. A lot that is past it and still taking bids stays in the live list marked Ending until the house closes it.
11
Before you bid
- Buyer’s premium. Auction houses add a premium to the winning bid, and tax and shipping come on top. Goldin lists 22% with a $19 minimum, ALT 20%, Fanatics Collect 20% in its Premier auctions and Cardova 6.05% to 11% including tax, by membership rank. A $1,000 winning bid at 22% costs $1,220 before tax and shipping. Work out the total you will pay, not the bid. Where Assetra knows the house’s rate, the price on the lot is labelled All-in cost and already includes it. The auction house results in Assetra’s ledger include the premium too, so a comp is comparable to your all-in cost.
- Closing rules. Know how the house you are bidding with closes before the night, as set out above, and read the terms on the lot itself.
- The slab itself. Check the cert number against the grader’s record before the final minutes, as in how to verify a graded slab.
12
After the hammer
A completed sale joins the card’s ledger and becomes the next comp. If you were watching the card, the result reaches you as a sale alert, whether you won, lost or sat the auction out, and the next time the card comes up you start with a fresher price.
About this article
Written and checked by Assetra. Prices and populations come from completed sales and the graders’ population reports as recorded in Assetra’s ledger; see how Assetra builds its figures. Spotted a mistake? Tell us.










