Assetra
Top SalesSales CompsPricesSetsLive Listings
Assetra
Navigate
01HomeRecord sales & market pulse02Market DataComps, prices & population03Live ListingsUnder the hammer now04Card SetsChecklists, market caps & movers
Also from us
Slabstoryslabstory.coGraded slabs for sale in collectors' Instagram stories, searchable by card or cert.
✶Intelligence for collectible markets
Assetra
Top SalesSales CompsPricesSetsLive Listings
Assetra
Navigate
01HomeRecord sales & market pulse02Market DataComps, prices & population03Live ListingsUnder the hammer now04Card SetsChecklists, market caps & movers
Also from us
Slabstoryslabstory.coGraded slabs for sale in collectors' Instagram stories, searchable by card or cert.
✶Intelligence for collectible markets
2017 Magearna #XY186 XY Black Star Promo PSA 10 graded card
2017 / Pokémon / XY Black Star Promo

Magearna#XY186

2017 Magearna #XY186 XY Black Star Promo PSA 10 graded card
PSA 10PSA10
2017 / Pokémon / XY Black Star Promo

2017 Pokémon XY Black Star Promo Magearna #XY186 PSA 10

Live auctioneBay
Current bid
$415−73%under value
UnderEst. value$1,563Above
41 bidsEnds in5D 1H
Bid on eBay
◆Market value
PSA 10
Last sale$1,600todayYTD+419%
Market trend
Jan 26today
PSA 10
Last sale$1,600todayYTD+419%
Market trend
Jan 26today
YTD sale range
Low$276Median$940High$4,800

Estimate basis: 24 recorded sales; latest sale Nov 16, 2026. How it is estimated

Recent PSA 10 comps in this view: 58 sales, Dec 14, 2025 – Nov 16, 2026.

▣Population report
DistributionTap to filter
◇Recent transactions
Total59
eBay
16 Nov 262d ago
Auction
PSA10
$1,600
Fanatics
09 Nov 269d ago
Auction
PSA10
$1,350
Alt
06 Nov 2612d ago
Auction
PSA10
$1,667
eBay
06 Nov 2612d ago
Fixed Price
PSA10
$2,575
eBay
02 Nov 2616d ago
Auction
PSA10
$2,025
❖Market insights

◆Price by grade

2017 Pokémon XY Black Star Promo Magearna #XY186: estimated value, latest sale and graded population at each grade, in US dollars, as of 18 Nov 2026.

PSA prices by grade

2017 Pokémon XY Black Star Promo Magearna #XY186: PSA price by grade in US dollars, as of 18 Nov 2026
GradeEstimateLast salePopulation
PSA 10$1,563$1,600 on 16 Nov 2026219
PSA 9$137$136 on 6 Nov 2026418
PSA 8n/a$50 on 4 Aug 2026163
CGC prices by grade
2017 Pokémon XY Black Star Promo Magearna #XY186: CGC price by grade in US dollars, as of 18 Nov 2026
GradeEstimateLast salePopulation
CGC Pristine 10n/a$675 on 9 Jun 20264
CGC 10$399$400 on 1 Oct 202617
CGC 9n/a$65 on 25 Apr 202645
BGS prices by grade
2017 Pokémon XY Black Star Promo Magearna #XY186: BGS price by grade in US dollars, as of 18 Nov 2026
GradeEstimateLast salePopulation
BGS 9.5$309$305 on 11 Nov 20262
24%reach PSA 10
3%reach CGC Pristine
✦Catalog entry№ 59574
Reference
PSA 10
Brand
Pokémon
Character
Magearna
Year
2017
Set
XY Black Star Promo→
Card №
XY186
Language
English
✦About this card101 recorded sales

A $4,800 record sale

2017 Pokémon XY Black Star Promo Magearna #XY186

PSA 10 estimate
$1,563
Latest PSA 10 sale
$1,600
16 Nov 2026
PSA 10 population
219
of 920 PSA graded (24%)

The 2017 Pokémon XY Black Star Promo Magearna #XY186 has an estimated PSA 10 value of $1,563 on Assetra. Its latest recorded PSA 10 sale was $1,600 on 16 Nov 2026, following $1,350 in November 2026.

Assetra tracks 101 recorded sales; the 99 most recent, 58 of them PSA 10, range from $40 to $4,800.

PSA population: 920 graded copies, 219 PSA 10 (24%). CGC and BGS: a further 149.

Based on 101 recorded sales through 16 Nov 2026. Past sales do not guarantee current value. How Assetra builds these numbers

Assetra

Intelligence for collectible markets

Assetra tracks the graded trading card market: sold prices and comps from the major auction houses, live auctions, PSA, BGS and CGC population reports, and market caps for every set across Pokémon, One Piece, Magic: The Gathering and Yu-Gi-Oh!

Market data

  • Graded card market report
  • Top card sales
  • Sold comps and price history
  • Live card auctions
  • Pokémon card auctions
  • Set market caps
  • Auction watchlist and alerts
  • Collection tracker
  • Price guides

    • Graded card prices
    • Pokémon card prices
    • One Piece card prices
    • Magic: The Gathering prices
    • Yu-Gi-Oh! card prices

    Popular sets

    • Pokémon Base Set
    • Team Rocket
    • Neo Genesis
    • Skyridge
    • Evolving Skies
    • Pokémon 151

    Learn

    • Market insights
    • Collecting guides
    • How we value cards
    • About Assetra
    • iPhone app
    • Contact us

    Legal

    • Privacy
    • Terms

    © 2026 Assetra. All rights reserved.

    Market data is provided for informational purposes only.

    ◆
    ◆ Same card

    Other listings

    eBay
    Pokemon Magearna XY186 Full Art Mythical Collection Black Star Promo GEM PSA 10
    —

    Pokemon Magearna Xy186 Full Art Mythical Collection Black Star Promo Gem Psa 10

    Asking price

    Pop 219
    $6,400
    300% over
    Buy It Now
    eBay
    *LOW POP FRESH CERT* Pokemon Magearna Black Star Promo XY186 PSA 10
    —

    *low Pop Fresh Cert* Pokemon Magearna Black Star Promo Xy186 Psa 10

    Fanatics
    2017 Pokemon XY Promo Mage Myth Alt Art Magearna #XY186 PSA 10 GEM MINT
    2017

    Pokemon Xy Promo Mage Myth Alt Art Magearna #xy186 Psa 10 Gem Mint

    eBay
    2017 POKEMON XY BLACK STAR PROMO #XY186 FULL ART/MAGEARNA PSA 10
    2017

    Pokemon Xy Black Star Promo #xy186 Full Art/magearna Psa 10

    eBay
    Magearna - 2017 Pokémon XY Black Star Promo XY186 Full Art - Low Pop
    2017

    Magearna - 2017 Pokémon Xy Black Star Promo Xy186 Full Art - Low Pop

    eBay
    Magearna XY186 Mythical Collection PSA 10 Pokemon Card *ZA
    —

    Magearna Xy186 Mythical Collection Psa 10 Pokemon Card *za

    eBay
    FRESH CERT! 2017 POKEMON XY BLACK STAR PROMO #XY186 FULL ART/MAGEARNA PSA 10
    2017

    Fresh Cert! 2017 Pokemon Xy Black Star Promo #xy186 Full Art/magearna Psa 10

    eBay
    Pokemon Magearna XY186 XY Black Star Promo Mythical Collection  PSA 10
    —

    Pokemon Magearna Xy186 Xy Black Star Promo Mythical Collection Psa 10

    ◆
    ◆ Same auction house

    More from eBay

    All 8848 →
    eBay
    ◆
    ◆ Under the hammer

    More Magearna

    All 4 →
    eBay

    Asking price

    Pop 219
    $6,000
    275% over
    Buy It Now
    #XY186

    Asking price

    Pop 219
    $6,000
    275% over
    Buy It Now

    Asking price

    Pop 219
    $5,400
    238% over
    Buy It Now

    Asking price

    Pop 219
    $5,000
    213% over
    Buy It Now

    Asking price

    Pop 219
    $4,250
    166% over
    Buy It Now

    Asking price

    Pop 219
    $4,199
    162% over
    Buy It Now

    Asking price

    Pop 219
    $3,799
    137% over
    Buy It Now
    Mew
    2026 · 30th Celebration

    Mew#B

    Current bid

    Pop 1
    $85,801
    47% under
    47 bids|22H 2M
    eBay
    Monkey D. Luffy
    2026 · The World's Strongest Warriors

    Monkey D. Luffy#061

    Current bid

    Pop 31
    $52,300
    39% under
    28 bids|2d
    eBay
    Lugia
    2003 · Aquapolis

    Lugia#149

    Current bid

    Pop 535
    $32,600
    13% over
    32 bids|1d
    eBay
    Monkey D. Luffy
    2025 · Carrying On His Will

    Monkey D. Luffy#118

    Current bid

    Pop 350
    $30,100
    17% under
    57 bids|14H 7M
    eBay
    Gol D. Roger
    2024 · Emperors In The New World

    Gol D. Roger#OP09118

    Current bid

    Pop 95
    $30,100
    40 bids|2d
    eBay
    Rayquaza EX
    2012 · Black & White Dragons Exalted

    Rayquaza ex#123

    Current bid

    Pop 137
    $25,600
    10% under
    33 bids|1d
    eBay
    Umbreon ex
    2026 · Black Star Promos

    Umbreon ex#110

    Current bid

    $25,100
    44 bids|1d
    eBay
    Charizard
    1999 · Base Set

    Charizard#4

    Current bid

    Pop 488
    $23,300
    32% under
    93 bids|6d
    Magearna
    2017 · XY Black Star Promo

    Magearna#XY186

    Current bid

    Pop 219
    $750
    52% under
    19 bids|1H 17M
    eBay
    Magearna
    2017 · XY Black Star Promo

    Magearna#XY186

    Current bid

    $156
    61% under
    3 bids|2d
    eBay
    Magearna
    2017 · XY Black Star Promo

    Magearna#XY186

    Current bid

    Pop 219
    $55
    96% under
    7 bids|5d